Published on:

Edgar Freeman Smith

I am reading “A Saga of Texas Law” by Edgar Freeman Smith, published  in 1940. It is a fascinating look into the not-so-distant past of the development of Texas law, and the story of a remarkable man.

E.F. Smith was born in 1889 in the lands of the Chickasaw Nation where his father was a missionary. His father died when he was a boy; he found work as a logger, a brick carrier and mercantile clerk, to support his mother. They moved from Oklahoma to Snyder, Texas, a new town being built on the new Texas & Pacific Railroad then being built; then a move to San Antonio, then back to Snyder. During this time he managed to complete a high school education.

But early on, as a young boy, E.F. always wanted to be a lawyer. His father had a large library including classics like Plato and Aristotle, which E.F. devoured. He was a voracious reader. He obtained law books and “read the law.” In 1914, at age 25, he took the bar exam, which at the time consisted of hundreds of written questions and took him five days. He passed, and paid the five dollars to get his license. He got work at the Scurry County Abstract Company in Snyder, and soon got his first client.

E.F.’s client had gotten into a fight with an enemy and was charged with disturbing the peace, “using profane and abusive language in a public place,” and aggravated assault. Seeking to relieve his client of the aggravated assault claim, which called for significant jail time, E.F. devised a plan. Appearing for the trial in Gail, Texas, in Borden County, he made a deal with the prosecutor: his client would plead guilty of disturbing the peace provided the judge would agree that his punishment for that crime would be the lowest penalty allowed by the law. Then they would go to trial on the other to counts. After the plea and sentence on the disturbing-the-peace count, E.F. moved to dismiss the other two counts on a plea of autro fois convict. The three counts all arose from the same event, and the law provided that his client, having been convicted of a crime arising out of that event, could not later be charged with other counts arising from the same altercation. The judge agreed and dismissed the two remaining counts. E.F. was paid $25 for his work.

E.F. served as mayor of Snyder, and then became assistant attorney general in the Texas Attorney General’s office, where he handled several high-profile and precedent-setting cases. He recounts several of those cases in his book, one of which is Greene vs. Robison, 117 Texas 516, the case construing the Texas Relinquishment Act. (I have written about the history of the Act.)

E.F. then joined the firm Baker, Botts, Parker & Garwood, where he argued six cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, winning five. He and his wife retired to California, where he died in 1972.

E.F. also has something to say about the Constitution and the Supreme Court, and I consider the following quotes from his book appropriate for the present times:

The people provided in the Constitution for short terms of office for all our public officials, except members of the Federal Judiciary. Every two years we elect all the members of the House of Representatives. One-third of our Senators are elected every two years. The President holds his office for four years. Our public elections are considered by some people as being little short of public nuisances. Our elections do disturb the peace and tranquillity of the people. This is a part of the price we must pay if we are to have the kind of government that is provided for in our Constitution. The statement is often made that our government is a democracy. The statement is inaccurate, for the people do not directly govern themselves. Under the form of government provided for in our Constitution, the people delegate the power to make, construe, and enforce the law to their chosen representatives. While the importance of having and maintaining a written constitution cannot be overemphasized, the fact remains that the kind of government that we are to have depends as much upon the kind and character of men whom the people elect to govern them as it does upon a written constitution. …

We Americans like to boast that the Supreme Court of the United States is the greatest court in the world. We are likely to forget that the court is never at any given time any better than the men who are the judges on the court. There have been some great lawyers on the court, a few judicial statesmen, and it has been a happy landing place for some astute and shrewd politicians. I am a member of the bar of the Supreme Court of the United States; and for the court and its functions, I have a profound respect. In my opinion, however, there are a number of state supreme courts that have a far better judicial record over a long period of years than has the Supreme Court of the United States. I will agree that in one thing the Supreme Court of the United States surpasses any other court in this country, and that is its capacity to contradict itself.

Contact Information