Published on:

Today the Texas Supreme Court denied JLMH’s motion for rehearing in Family Dollar Stores of Texas, LLC v. JLMH Investments, LLC, No. 24-053. The Court’s opinions in the case were issued last summer. Members issued four opinions: the opinion of the court, written by Justice Busby, “with respect to Part II,” joined by Justices Blacklock, Lehrmann, Devine, Bland, Huddle and Young; an opinion by Justice Busby “with respect to Part I,” joined by Justices Lehrmann and Devine; a concurring opinion by Justice Young, joined by Justices Bland and Huddle, and by Justice Blacklock “as to Part II”; and a dissenting opinion by Justice Sullivan, joined by Justices Blacklock and Hawkins.  Pretty confusing.

“Part I” dealt with whether the trial court’s opinion was final and whether the court of appeals had jurisdiction to review the case. Part II dealt with the application of the statute of limitations for JLMH’s claims. Justices Sullivan, Blacklock and Hawkins concluded that the judgment was not final and the court of appeals had no jurisdiction. The other six justices agreed that the trial court’s judgment was final and held that JLMH’s claims were barred by the two-year statute of limitations.

Family Dollar had a store on a tract adjacent to JLMH’s property, completed in 2016. JLMH then noticed that its property began to flood every time it rained, depositing silt and trash and turning the north side of its property into a swamp, affecting JLMH’s building and parking lot. JLMH first sought help from the City of Fort Worth, but its attempts availed nothing. In 2019 JLMH retained an engineering company to inspect its building, and the engineer found that the flooding caused the groundwater on its property to increase and destabilized the building. JLMH sued Family Dollar in 2020, alleging trespass, negligent and intentional diversion of water, and violations of a Water Code provision prohibiting diversion of the natural flow of surface waters, creating a nuisance. JLMH sought damages and an injunction to force Family Dollar to fix the problem. The trial court granted Family Dollar’s motion for summary judgment based on the fact that the claims were not made within two years of JLMH’s discovery of the problem.

Published on:

I am reading “A Saga of Texas Law” by Edgar Freeman Smith, published  in 1940. It is a fascinating look into the not-so-distant past of the development of Texas law, and the story of a remarkable man.

E.F. Smith was born in 1889 in the lands of the Chickasaw Nation where his father was a missionary. His father died when he was a boy; he found work as a logger, a brick carrier and mercantile clerk, to support his mother. They moved from Oklahoma to Snyder, Texas, a new town being built on the new Texas & Pacific Railroad then being built; then a move to San Antonio, then back to Snyder. During this time he managed to complete a high school education.

But early on, as a young boy, E.F. always wanted to be a lawyer. His father had a large library including classics like Plato and Aristotle, which E.F. devoured. He was a voracious reader. He obtained law books and “read the law.” In 1914, at age 25, he took the bar exam, which at the time consisted of hundreds of written questions and took him five days. He passed, and paid the five dollars to get his license. He got work at the Scurry County Abstract Company in Snyder, and soon got his first client.

Published on:

The Texas Supreme Court recently declined to hear the Eckford Heirs’ appeal in Case No. 26-0003, Heirs of Eckford v. Nixon et al. The Court of Appeals’ opinion is Eckford v. Korth, 2025 WL 2845033 (Tex.App.-San Antonio, Oct. 8, 2025). The case was the subject of a Texas Monthly article, One Family Worked the Land for Generations. Another Believes They Lost an Inheritance. Both Are Still Waiting (Sept. 12, 2025).

The suit is over title to 147.5 acres of land in Karnes County, in the heart of the Eagle Ford play. The land was acquired by Louis and Eliza Eckford, freed from slavery on June 19, 1865. They had nine children. Louis died in 1896 without a will. According to the Texas Monthly article,

The 1880 census listed Louis as a farmer, and the Eckfords were among the early residents of a settlement described in a local paper as a community of “intelligent, progressive and prosperous colored people.” But their hold on the land, and their prosperity, proved to be tenuous. Just three years after the last purchase, records show Louis was declared insane by a local jury and transferred to what was known as the Texas State Lunatic Asylum in Austin.

Published on:

Here is a hypothetical: OilCo A and OilCo B each acquire oil and gas leases from mineral owners holding undivided interests in Blackacre. The two companies are unable to agree on a joint operating agreement. OilCo A drills and completes wells, and OilCo B becomes a non-consenting cotenant, entitled to its share of net profit from the wells after payout. Issue: When does OilCo B owe royalties to its royalty owners?

Those are the facts in Pioneer Natural Resources USA, Inc., v. Elberta M. Royalty, LLC (Tex.App.-El Paso, August 19, 2026). Pioneer and Henry Petroleum each held oil and gas leases covering the same land in Upton County. Pioneer’s lease was from Elberta M. Royalty. Henry drilled wells without a joint operating agreement from Pioneer. Pioneer did not respond to Elberta’s demands for payment of royalty, and Elberta filed suit. While the suit was pending the wells paid out, Henry paid Pioneer its share of revenue, and Pioneer then paid Elberta its share of royalty from the date of first production – two years after production began. (Pioneer and Henry subsequently did enter into a joint operating agreement.) Elberta claimed it was also entitled to statutory interest and attorneys’ fees under Texas Natural Resources Code Chapter 91.

The Court of Appeals held that Pioneer’s obligation to pay royalty under Elberta’s lease accrued when production occurred, not when Pioneer got paid, including statutory interest.

Published on:

The Railroad Commission is governed by three commissioners, each elected stat-wide for six-year terms. This year the race is between Democrat Jon Rosenthal and Bo French, who defeated the incumbent Jim Wright in the Republican primary.

Jon Rosenthal served eight years in the Texas House of representatives, has experience as a drilling rig equipment engineer and a subsea technology systems engineer. He wants to partner with industry to increase weatherization of the gas midstream segment; lobby the Legislature to increase funding for plugging of orphan wells; increase required security bonds required of operators without a responsible history; and return some local control of well drilling in municipalities.

Bo French has called for the denaturalization and deporation of 100 million Americans. He says two state Representatives, Salman Bhojani and Gene Wu, should be denaturalized and deported. He is an advocate of the “great replacement theory,” promoting a comspiracy by liberals or a secret cable to replace descendants of white settlers with immigrants. He wants to deregulate the oil and gas industry.

Published on:

In my writings I have mostly shied away from politics. I must make an exception here.

Those of us in the oil and gas space know what the Railroad Commission does. Most voters do not. Bo French defeated incumbent Jim Wright in the Republican primary by one percent. Jim Wright was qualified by his experience to be a commissioner. He was endorsed by Governor Abbott in the Republican primary, who warned voters that French “doesn’t know anything about oil and gas” and would “wreck” oil production. French’s democratic opponent is Jon Rosenthal. Rosenthal is a petroleum engineer with 25 years. experience in the industry.

Here are excerpts from Bo French’s platform:

Published on:

Recently the El Paso Court of Appeals affirmed a judgment denying Tom Craddick’s claim that Cimarex and BPX had conspired to wash out his overriding royalty interest in an oil and gas lease owned by BPX. Craddick v. Cimarex Energy, et al., No. 08-24-00010-CV.

An overriding royalty is created when the owner of an oil and gas lease assigns the lease but reserves a royalty interest in production. An overriding royalty can also be created by assignment from the lessee. Because the overriding royalty is carved out of the lessee’s working interest, it terminates when the lease terminates.

A “washout” of an overriding royalty occurs when the lessee releases the lease even though there is a well or wells on the lease that continues to produce in paying quantities. The overriding royalty is “washed out” by the release.

Published on:

Last month the Texas Supreme Court decided three cases involving Texas’ Open Beaches Act. The Court issued one opinion in all three cases: No. 24-0237, Texas General Land Office and Dawn Buckingham, in her official capacity as the Texas Land Commissioner, v. SaveRGV, Sierra Club, and Carrizo/Comecrudo Nation of Texas, Inc.; No 24-0407, Cameron County v. SaveRGV, Sierra Club, and Carrizo/Comecrudo Nation of Texas Inc; and No. 24-0457, Ken Paxton, in his official capacity as Attorney General of Texas, v. Save RGV, Sierra Club, and Carrizo/Comecrudo Nation of Texas, Inc.  The cases reminded me of a little Texas history.

The three plaintiffs filed suit because in 2013 the Legislature passed HB 2623, amending the Open Beaches Act, Tex. Nat. Res. Code Chapter 61, to authorize the General Land Office and Cameron County to adopt rules allowing them to temporarily close beaches “for space flight activities.” The bill passed at the request of SpaceX, which maintains a launch site on Boca Chica Beach on the coast in Cameron County (now incorporated as the town of Starbase. The GLO and the county have at restricted access to Boca Chica beach when SpaceX launches take place.

Boca-Chica
Plaintiffs claimed that HB 2623 violates Article I, Section 33 of the Texas Constitution, approved by voters in 2009, which states:

Published on:

As we are on the cusp of celebrating the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and the remarkable fact that our nation has survived so long, it seems a good time to share a speech given by Lee West at the Oklahoma Bar Association Rule of Law Conference at Oklahoma City University School of Law on April 11, 2008, published by the Oklahoma City University Law Review in Spring 2009, Vol. 34, Number 1. I had the pleasure of knowing Judge West, who was District Judge for the Western District of Oklahoma from 1979 until he took senior status in 1994, but he continued to serve as judge after that. He died in 2020, age 90.  A wonderful interview of Judge West recounting his youth in Oklahoma during the Great Depression, published by the Oklahoma Historical Society, can be found here.

Below are excepts from his speech, which has remarkable parallels to current attacks on the rule of law. (I can provide a copy of the full speech to anyone who requests it.)

Good afternoon. It is a genuine honor to be among so many friends and colleagues. I may not deserve this honor, but I am recovering from kidney-stone surgery, and I guarantee you I do not deserve that either. This morning you have heard eloquent descriptions and defenses of the rule of law. After such fascinating presentations, I am hard pressed to add anything. Honestly, being asked to speak in the wake of so many distinguished judges, lawyers, doctors, businessmen, and academics feels a little bit like being asked on a date by a porn star. Any anticipation of personal enjoyment is tempered by performance anxiety—the expectation that my efforts, however enthusiastic, will be judged by a punishing professional standard. In all seriousness, the rule of law is a broad and important subject, and I confess I am a serious student who continues to learn from conferences such as this one. Of course, my perspective on the topic cannot help but be shaped by my long experience as a state and federal judge. My thirty-seven years on the bench have only reinforced my appreciation for our Founders’ genius.

Published on:

Oil and gas leases that cover larger tracts — say 300 acres or more — should contain a retained acreage clause.

A retained acreage clause has two parts: defining how much acreage will be kept under lease by a well and requiring the lessee to designate that acreage; and defining when the retained acreage must be designated and lands outside the retained acreage tracts released. The idea is to allow the operator to retain the acreage, and only the acreage, being drained by each well.

The amount of acreage (and depths) retained by a well may depend on whether the well is vertical or horizontal; whether the well is classified as a gas well or an oil well; and the depth of the perforated interval. Before the development of horizontal well technology and the ability to produce from tight unconventional formations, retained acreage clauses generally allowed units for oil wells of 40 acres and units for gas wells of 160 acres. For deeper production, units could be 80 acres for oil and 320 acres or even 640 acres for gas. It was generally assumed that a gas well would drain a larger area in a conventional field than an oil well.

Contact Information