Published on:

Family Dollar Stores v. JLMH: what is a nuisance and when can you sue for one?

Today the Texas Supreme Court denied JLMH’s motion for rehearing in Family Dollar Stores of Texas, LLC v. JLMH Investments, LLC, No. 24-053. The Court’s opinions in the case were issued last summer. Members issued four opinions: the opinion of the court, written by Justice Busby, “with respect to Part II,” joined by Justices Blacklock, Lehrmann, Devine, Bland, Huddle and Young; an opinion by Justice Busby “with respect to Part I,” joined by Justices Lehrmann and Devine; a concurring opinion by Justice Young, joined by Justices Bland and Huddle, and by Justice Blacklock “as to Part II”; and a dissenting opinion by Justice Sullivan, joined by Justices Blacklock and Hawkins.  Pretty confusing.

“Part I” dealt with whether the trial court’s opinion was final and whether the court of appeals had jurisdiction to review the case. Part II dealt with the application of the statute of limitations for JLMH’s claims. Justices Sullivan, Blacklock and Hawkins concluded that the judgment was not final and the court of appeals had no jurisdiction. The other six justices agreed that the trial court’s judgment was final and held that JLMH’s claims were barred by the two-year statute of limitations.

Family Dollar had a store on a tract adjacent to JLMH’s property, completed in 2016. JLMH then noticed that its property began to flood every time it rained, depositing silt and trash and turning the north side of its property into a swamp, affecting JLMH’s building and parking lot. JLMH first sought help from the City of Fort Worth, but its attempts availed nothing. In 2019 JLMH retained an engineering company to inspect its building, and the engineer found that the flooding caused the groundwater on its property to increase and destabilized the building. JLMH sued Family Dollar in 2020, alleging trespass, negligent and intentional diversion of water, and violations of a Water Code provision prohibiting diversion of the natural flow of surface waters, creating a nuisance. JLMH sought damages and an injunction to force Family Dollar to fix the problem. The trial court granted Family Dollar’s motion for summary judgment based on the fact that the claims were not made within two years of JLMH’s discovery of the problem.

The Court of Appeals held that JLMH’s suit for damages was barred by limitations but it could sue for an injunction, holding that “limitations is not a defense to an injunction requesting abatement of a nuisance.” The Supreme Court disagreed.

The Supreme Court has previously held that, if a nuisance is “permanent”, the statute of limitations on a cause of action for damages begins to accrue when the damages become known. If a nuisance is “temporary,” then the injured party can sue for damages accruing within two years of when the suit is brought, and can seek injunctive relief to abate the nuisance. And the Court held in Schneider National Carriers, Inc. v. Bates, 147 S.W.3d 264, 281 (Tex. 2004) that “a nuisance should be deemed permanent if it is sufficiently constant or regular (no matter how long between occurrences) that future impact can be reasonably evaluated.” In Family Dollar, the nuisance was “permanent”;  the Court held that the two-year statute of limitation barred all remedies–whether damages or injunctive relief. Result: Family Dollar could continue to flood JLMH’s property with impunity. It waited too late to sue.

The result here certainly seems harsh. The Court could have created an exception allowing suits to abate any nuisance, whether temporary or permanent. It declined to do so. Part of the problem is the short two-year limitations statute, which applies to most tort claims in Texas — shorter than the limitations statutes in many other states.

Posted in:
Published on:
Updated:

Comments are closed.

Contact Information